How we calculate
Install cost
Drawn from aggregated MCS installation records (2024 calendar year). We use a low–high range to reflect regional variation, complexity (radiator upgrades, pipework, cylinder replacements), and installer pricing differences. Mid-point is shown for payback calculations.
Heat demand
Per-property heat demand baselines come from Energy Saving Trust modelling, adjusted by an insulation multiplier:
- Good insulation: 85% of base demand
- Average insulation: 100% of base demand
- Poor insulation: 125% of base demand
Running cost
Calculated as useful heat × cost per kWh of heat delivered. Cost per kWh of
heat depends on fuel efficiency and tariff:
- Heat pump on Octopus Cosy: £0.06–£0.08 per kWh useful heat
- Heat pump on standard variable: £0.065–£0.085 per kWh useful heat
- Gas boiler: £0.085 per kWh useful heat
- Oil boiler: £0.105 per kWh useful heat
- LPG boiler: £0.155 per kWh useful heat
- Direct electric: £0.27 per kWh useful heat
These figures are updated each time Ofgem revises the price cap (quarterly). Last refresh: Q4 2024.
Payback period
Calculated as net install cost (after grant) ÷ annual running cost saving.
Where saving is zero or negative, payback is "N/A" — the heat pump is run on running-cost
grounds alone, not financial payback.
What we don't model (yet)
- Annual maintenance cost differences (typically minor: £80–£150/yr both for HPs and gas boilers)
- Equipment replacement at end of life (HP unit ~15–20 yrs; boiler ~10–15 yrs)
- Carbon emissions / future carbon pricing
- EPC rating uplift effect on property value
These each have modest effect on totals but compound over time. Conservatively, modelling them tends to improve the heat pump case further — particularly versus oil and LPG.
Sources
- MCS installation cost data: MCS Installation Database, 2024.
- Heat demand baselines: Energy Saving Trust, "Heat Pump Performance Study", 2024.
- Energy prices: Ofgem default tariff cap, Q4 2024.
- Octopus Cosy rates: Octopus Energy public tariff page, accessed quarterly.
- SCOP figures: BEIS heat pump efficiency dataset, 2023.